• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Times Square Pizzeria: Fresh, Flavorful Pizza & Comfort Food in Lexington, NC

***About Times Square Pizzeria***

Nestled in Lexington, NC, Times Square Pizzeria promises hot, fresh, and flavorful food that’s a hit with locals. Renowned for its homemade crust and delectable toppings, the pizzeria offers a standout Buffalo chicken and chicken Alfredo pizza that customers rave about. Diners enjoy a variety of options, including the Philly Cheese Steak sandwich, often paired with enticing deals. While some reviews indicate inconsistency, many praise the friendly service and overall pleasant dining experience. Whether you're ordering in or dining at the modest tables, Times Square Pizzeria stands out as a go-to destination for pizza enthusiasts seeking satisfying meals.

Photos & Gallery

Times Square Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Tiffany Hunt
Tiffany Hunt

Pizza is always hot and fresh. The Buffalo chicken is my favorite. I got chicken Alfredo tonight, and it is absolutely the best Alfredo I've had! Highly recommend this pizza joint.

Debbie Stegall
Debbie Stegall

The Philly Cheese Steak sandwich was very good and the price was $10. The gentleman who took my order was kind enough to tell me about a special that they had going on. I could get the Cheese Steak sandwich plus French fries and a drink for $9.99. saved a penny and got more food. The staff was nice.

Rebecca M.
Rebecca M.

Can't rate service & atmosphere since we've only ever done delivery orders, but the food is really hit or miss. The first time we had pizza from this place we ordered a cheese pizza, garlic knots, and a combo pizza. It was very good. Hot, fresh, & good flavor. The 2nd time, we ordered the chicken Alfredo pizza & the garlic knots. The chicken alfredo pizza was saltier than the ocean. Even my husband who loves salt couldn't eat that pizza, so we ended up tossing it, which was an absolute waste of money. Also for some reason the garlic knots had different toppings for some reason??? Tonight we thought to give it one more try and ordered garlic knots and the Meatball parmesean pizza. The ingredients listed on this pizza says "meatballs, tomato sauce, basil, & mozzarella". However we received a pizza doused in giant globs of unseasoned ricotta. I love ricotta, but not like that. It was quite flavorless and also was not a listed ingredient. And once again, this was a pizza made for the trash can. Probably won't be a returning customer at this point.

Steven Friddle
Steven Friddle

Pizza is typically really good. it's a thinner, crisper crust, then most places which, in my opinion, is how pizza should be. Staff is usually pretty friendly, not a lot of interaction past ordering and picking up food which is to be expected in this style of restaurant. Over all, pleasant experience, good food.

Veronica Hamilton
Veronica Hamilton

The pizza was delicious. The crust was homemade, delicious and baked just right. The sauce is not too tart and not sweet. The cheese was good quality. Overall, the pizza and service were fantastic. There are table and chairs but it is mostly a takeout place. The prices are reasonable.

Scott Daniels
Scott Daniels

Some of the best New York style pizza found south of the Mason Dixon. Staff is fast and courteous.

David Madama
David Madama

Good pizza. Nice people. Never any problems. Taste like real pizza not like most of the other places. If you grew up on Dominoes and frozen you might not like it. Originally from Jersey. It's hard to find a good pie around here

Location

If you find yourself in Lexington, NC, make sure to stop by Times Square Pizzeria, nestled at 828 Winston Rd. A popular treasure among locals and visitors alike, this pizzeria combines the best of traditional pizza making with innovative flavors that surely delight the palate.

From the moment you step in or call for delivery, you're welcomed by a friendly staff eager to make your dining experience memorable. The atmosphere is casual yet inviting, making it a perfect spot for a quick bite or a relaxed meal with friends and family. However, as several reviews suggest, dining in is not the primary draw—takeout seems to be the favored choice for many.

One standout feature of Times Square Pizzeria is the dough used for their crust. Customers rave about its thin and crisp texture, offering an excellent base for a variety of toppings. The homemade quality shines through, ensuring each piece is not only enjoyable but also a testament to great craftsmanship in pizza-making.

Among their offerings, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza gets high praise from Tiffany Hunt, who mentions it's her favorite. The combination of spicy buffalo sauce with tender chicken gives it an irresistible kick that pizza lovers crave. And for those seeking something different, the Chicken Alfredo Pizza is touted for its creamy goodness—although caution may be advised based on mixed reviews regarding its seasoning consistency.

But it’s not just pizza that delights here. For those looking to try something beyond the pie, the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich has also garnered positive feedback. Debbie Stegall highlighted its value during a recent visit, appreciating not just the flavor but also the affordable pricing, paired with fries and a drink, making it a fantastic deal at under $10.

Despite some polarizing opinions, the overall consensus remains that Times Square Pizzeria delivers satisfying dining experiences inspired by classic Italian fare. Some customers, like Steven Friddle, note that while food quality is consistent, there may be occasional lapses in the kitchen, as seen in mixed reviews regarding flavor balance in certain dishes. However, the friendly demeanor of their staff appears to create a welcoming environment that can often outweigh minor discrepancies in food preparation.

In conclusion, if you are in the mood for pizza that balances homemade charm with bold flavors, Times Square Pizzeria deserves a spot on your food itinerary. With a variety of options and the promise of freshness, it’s a culinary destination for anyone craving not just a meal, but an experience—delivered hot and straight to your door or enjoyed in-house.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards